Sunday, November 1, 2015

Science vs. Religion: A False Dichotomy

At the forefront of the debate surrounding education and homeschool is the importance of religious education versus secular education. I would conjecture that the overwhelming majority of decisions to homeschool revolve around this singular issue. While there is definitely time to supplement a secular education with a religious one, there are a few topics on which these two elements inevitably clash.

When I was a Sophomore in High School, I took a Biology class from a very engaging and knowledgeable teacher who, on our first day of that class, gave us a unique assignment that was to be completed in class. He requested that we briefly write about whether we believe in Creationism or in Evolution, and to explain why. After collecting our responses, he read some of them out loud to the class, tossing away any that supported Creationism, while reading through the few that embraced the Theory of Evolution all the way through with a subtle nod of approval. Many of these were, in my opinion, not well written; but it didn't matter since they apparently demonstrated enough intellectual insight as to conform to the belief of the scientific community. On the other hand, appeals to a faith-based theory of the origin of life were eschewed as primitive, unenlightened, and wholly lacking critical thought.

At the time, I thought little of this exercise, which of course was the prelude to a class whose foundation was Charles Darwin's Theory of Evolution. A decade later, however, I witnessed this conflict resurface in the academic community with renewed vehemence. Parents would oppose the teaching of the Theory of Evolution with futility, while any teacher who suggested that life could have been created by God, or even by means of the more neutral "intelligent design" were reprimanded for teaching something that was not science. To no one's surprise, many disillusioned families continue to withdraw their children from public school to either homeschool, or to send them to a private school that ensures a solid religious opinion on topics of science, history, and reading. This decision is often criticized for failing to adequately prepare students for higher education, where a solid understanding of Darwin's Theory of Evolution is a requirement especially in science degrees.

Eventually, every student must resolve this conflict within him or herself. On this philosophy alone, one is immediately classified as either an intellectual and a critical thinker or a theologian and a religious person. Just as it is in politics, where one is expected to be either a liberal or a conservative, a student must choose one of these two beliefs, as though it were not possible for both or even neither to be correct. In fact, Evolution and Creationism are what we may nominate a "false dichotomy". It is not an either/or proposition.

To round out this concept, we must retreat to a more basic discipline: philosophy. Philosophy is the essence of how one comes to learn truth, and how one defines truth. Truth may be defined as "things as they really are" and for the sake of simplicity, one may approach this in one of two ways: truth is relative, or truth is absolute. I believe truth is absolute. This philosophy stabilizes my world view, and my self-concept. Absolute truth does not change based on what people believe or say, but it is immutable and composes a sphere that is greater than I am. On the other hand, a belief in relative truth is unstable and weak, since it subjugates everything to an individual's beliefs, passions, vices, appetites, and whims. This can do nothing except destroy that man who embraces a belief in relative truth, as he can never elevate himself above his self-exalted post.

Accepting now that all truth is absolute, we must now ponder how truth is learned and understood. In short, how do we know that something is true? Also, from whence does truth originate? I believe that God is the author of all truth, and therefore, God knows all truth. This belief that God is over everything, and that He is our Heavenly Father is the foundation of my faith, and therefore my religion.

I believe that my existence on Earth is a key part of His eternal plan for me, and for everyone. I believe that the universe that He created is governed by eternal laws, (or eternal truths) which must deal justly with people like me who sin, and therefore are unfit to dwell in the presence of God, who is perfect and without sin. I believe that our Heavenly Father loves us so much that He sent His Son, Jesus Christ, to conquer death through His Resurrection, and to atone for the sins of the world, thus allowing the repentant sinner to be cleansed from sin and overcome death in order to return to our Heavenly Father. What I believe to be the "Gospel" or "good news" of Jesus Christ is the manner of living that He has ordained for us to live in order for His grace, or in other words, the power of his atonement to work in our lives to the perfectioning of our immortal souls. I know this, because Jesus Christ proclaimed of himself in the Holy Bible in the Book of John "I am the way, the truth, and the light". Jesus Christ, like His Father, is the way to all truth. This profound belief that I have is truth that I have learned through the medium which God has appointed that all truth may be learned by man: through the Holy Spirit. The Book of Mormon, a volume of ancient scripture that, like the Bible, contains the fullness of the Gospel of Jesus Christ, teaches in the Book of Moroni that "by the power of the Holy Ghost, ye may know the truth of all things". Thus, truth is understood by that sublime power.

Drawing this within the context of education, I believe that God's plan for us is to learn about things that are on this earth, as well as those things which pertain to a heavenly sphere. I believe that it is important for us to obtain as much education as possible, and to acquire knowledge of things that are true. What we call "science" is the means by which come to discover truth. Indeed, the history of the world is a chronicle of knowledge being compounded upon knowledge, and discovery being made upon discovery. It is a story of learning, and continual advancement. From spears to firearms, from horses to airplanes, from monarchy to republic, and from scrolls to cell phones, mankind continues to advance in knowledge and understanding because of discoveries that are made about how the universe really is. Just like the earth did not suddenly become round when man discovered that it was round, science is not always synonymous with truth. Our scientific understanding of how things are is the product of observation, hypothesis, testing, retesting, conclusion, theory, and then continuing to repeat the cycle. When something continues to demonstrate a similar result (something that we call "empirical evidence") we then assume that things are really as we see them. The very essence of science applauds continual skepticism, as it should, yet this does not seem to apply to elements of science that appear at times to serve little purpose except to attack tenets of Christian faith. That is, the scientific community is ready to go to arms over the suggestion that the universe may be the product of something greater than ourselves, that we do not as of yet fully comprehend. I understand that it is not proper for science to work in reverse, that is, it should not seek evidence simply because it has been written in scripture. However, is there not room in this ardently secular school of thought to admit that we may not and cannot have all of the answers by relying on our own abilities?

This is exactly why science should not oppose religion any more than religion should oppose science. Albert Einstein is credited with having said "Science without religion is lame, religion without science is blind". They are not mutually exclusive, nor are they acronyms. Instead, both are means by which mankind can come to understand truth, and have knowledge of things as they really are. As future homeschool teachers, we intend to convey this idea to our pupils. For my part, I love science, and I am ever fascinated and ever learning the elements of this wonderful and key discipline of education. In the spirit of a scientist, I question what I observe; and based upon what I believe to be true as revealed by the Holy Spirit (as every search for truth has its foundation), there are some tenets of conventional scientific wisdom that I simply cannot believe. It does not mean that I will not teach them, but I certainly cannot, with a clear conscience, teach them as though they were truth. This deviant approach to education will most likely serve a community of like-minded thinkers. If we are perfectly candid, it must be observed that most significant discoveries were made by those who did not share the view of their peers.

Saturday, October 24, 2015

An Introduction

Welcome to Summit Crest Institute of Autodidacts and Scholars!

Summit Crest Institute is the name of the academic institution created by Melissa and I, and this blog serves as a forum for the foundation and organization of it. It is our public channel, where our readers may expect to find news, narratives, essays, opinion articles, and other engaging and informative writings.

For my part, I would like to provide a bit of background as to what led us to establish Summit Crest Institute, why it is so named, and our vision of its purpose and future.

I have always loved to learn, and frankly I have been very successful at it. I was fortunate to study under very diligent and proficient teachers up through my secondary education that provided a strong knowledge base whereupon I could expect to improve with more in-depth study. Unfortunately, I was also free-spirited, and a bit lazy, so my otherwise promising academic career was halted, and I instead pursued a myriad of other engagements. I served an LDS mission to Argentina, and returned home and immediately began to work in my father's vocation, as an electrical worker. I was driven by a passion for flight at that time, one that had always driven me to stay busy in the available and lucrative construction industry. I poured my money and time into aviation, but this, too, met a rapid end when I married Melissa, and my money no longer belonged to me.

At length, I began to weary of the intellectually oppressive construction industry, and I sought a college education as a means of escape. I enjoyed learning tremendously, but I was disillusioned by two troubling observations. The first was that college was ridiculously, and inexplicably expensive. The second was that, helpful that my professors were, I was able to learn nearly all of the coursework from a textbook, and the internet. In fact, I frequently surpassed my classmates who were learning that which was "going to be on the test" and I enriched my mind with additional and pertinent knowledge for the sake of learning it. I determined that the learning isn't a gift from a college. It is a gift of the soul. This philosophy pushed me finally from college, and I concluded that I shall learn these things on my own, and just as well as if I had gone to school.

One of the things that I love about my beautiful wife, Melissa, is her firm commitment to personally oversee the education of all of our children. As I, like any parent, desire the best for my children, I proposed a vehicle for this end: Summit Crest Institute of Autodidacts and Scholars. As an institution of learning (a school, if you will), it is not unlike a university in its goals and objectives. On the one hand, it is an institute of scholars (students) and on the other it is an institute of autodidacts, those who are self taught. We have seen that learning is present as much in the teaching as it is in the completion of classes, and this way we limit no one in the promotion of his or her own education. While Summit Crest Institute will be the school which our children attend, it will simultaneously be the school that we attend. The only difference is, that school is never over, and graduation is only from one level to another, without finale. Like cresting a mountain summit only to find another peak to conquer, Summit Crest encompasses the idea that education is a lifelong journey, rather than a one-time event. The goal is to persevere in learning and discovery.

This is Summit Crest Institute of Autodidacts and Scholars.